diminished responsibility: domestic abuse

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. The 51 year-old was sentenced to seven years and three months in jail. Challen was denied the opportunity to raise the plea of provocation and unsuccessfully resorted to the defence of diminished responsibility, on the basis she was suffering from a depressive disorder at the time of the killing. ��L%�0��Ұ���L$�� z/�&8�ncz2e�|J���Y�݋:���� Evidence of coercive and controlling behaviour was put before the jury and it took them little time to return a verdict of manslaughter. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., Feb 28, 2013 - Law - 410 pages. Additionally, the fact that an accused is also a victim of domestic abuse will be considered throughout the criminal … A main requirement from the previous law has however been removed, the loss of self control no longer needs to be sudden, this may make it easier for those who suffer from domestic violence to raise a defence of ‘loss of self control’ instead of being stigmatised with having to raise a defence of “diminished responsibility”. Domestic violence exists within society as a pattern of controlling behaviour, which includes physical, emotional, sexual, financial and psychological abuse of one person by another.1 Government statistics indicate that around twenty eight percent of women have experienced some form of domestic violence since the age of sixteen. Latest criminal cases, including police assault; appeals out of time; diminished responsibility; dangerous dogs; sentencing, including children; consent to intercourse; and a note on the new abuse law . Actions. ", Stuart Lawrence inspires at Stroud Book Festival, Dursley knifeman charged with robbing woman of car outside Tesco, Old Down Play Area reopens following £40,000 refurbishment, Star of John Lewis Christmas ad shone at Stroud Fringe Festival, All the festive markets taking place in Cirencester this Christmas, Information about BBC links to other news sites, Teachers tear-gassed at protest against Sudan coup. Found inside – Page 116to both these issues, juries will continue to impose murder convictions unless they are made aware of the dynamics, the severity and the effects of domestic violence. (c) Diminished responsibility It is apparent from the case law that ... The reformed defences of loss of control and diminished responsibility are assessed in light of the implications of coercive and controlling behaviour in pleading the defences. Found insideS. Edwards, 'Loss of Self-Control: When His Anger is Worth More than Her Fear', in A. Reed and M. Bohlander (eds), Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives, Farnham: Ashgate ... It looks to the potential space for development that has been created by the recent case of Graham v HM Advocate, concluding that such a more would be an important step and one with significant implications for domestic abuse policy and the treatment of female accused more widely. This time I am part of the legal team that argues the appeal against her conviction for the murder of her husband, Richard, on behalf of Sally Challen. responsibility Assault - domestic Brain damage resulting from alcohol abuse PG Nil significant MT 4y AT 16m AD Killed wife with hammer No previous violence towards wife Troja NSWCCA 16.7.1991 Diminished responsibility Shooting - domestic Depressive illness VG nil MT 8y AT 4y AD Shot husband who was having affair and wanted divorce – shot through glass door with rifle Fryer NSWCCA … ESTABLISHING THE DOMESTIC HOMICIDE REVIEW [DHR] 2.1 Decision Making 2.1.1 In December 2012 the Chair of Sefton Safer Communities Partnership determined Throughout the report the term ‘domestic abuse’ is used interchangeably with ‘domestic violence’, and the report uses the cross-Government definition as issued in March 2013. Found inside – Page 89Battered woman syndrome is not a psychiatric diagnosis , and therefore will rarely constitute sufficient grounds for a diminished responsibility defence . However , the psychological , behavioural and cognitive deficits encompassed ... Whilst the court importantly recognised that a loss of control following the provocation should be ‘sudden’ (to use the language of the defence) it did not have to be immediate. https://www.buckingham.ac.uk/directory/professor-susan-edwards The Court also accepted Kiranjit’s plea of diminished responsibility as she was suffering from severe depression. First published in 1997, this book marks a culmination of a three year research programme focused upon the incidence of domestic violence in Leicester. Sara pleaded guilty on the grounds of diminished responsibility at the trial, a plea which focused on her own state of mind rather than the beatings she had received. Terms of Use staff access, CWJ EQUALITY POLICIES Privacy Policy, Copyright © 2016 - CENTRE FOR WOMEN'S JUSTICE a Charitable Incorporated Organisation: Charity No. Source: Local Media 1.4 The couple were not known to main stream agencies for domestic abuse. It was widely reported and the appellate process was the subject of a 90-minute BBC2 documentary. In the circumstances of domestic abuse, the partial defences relating to “loss of control” or diminished responsibility can also be argued. The issue of diminished responsibility is complex and raises issues of medical evidence and what disposal is appropriate considering the circumstances of the case. Found inside – Page 332Second, cases in which the defense suggests that the parent had diminished responsibility due to the extreme stress associated with raising a child with a disability may receive substantial widespread public attention if the prosecution ... 29 Jul 08 13:14 . I stabbed him in the heart. Murder suspect Sheila Lockridge has pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of manslaughter due to diminished responsibility. 17th June 2019 | Frank Crowe . Domestic Abuse Commissioner and Victims Commissioner for England and Wales outline concerns in joint letter to top government legal officials ... on the grounds of diminished responsibility … When the defence is successfully pleaded it has the effect of reducing a murder conviction to manslaughter. Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives. Found inside – Page 1His counsel have pleaded diminished responsibility and the court has requested psychological reports. What could possibly cause a man to in ̄ict such a vicious and frenzied attack on someone he was once so close to? 1 In 2017, 1.2 million 2 women experienced domestic abuse in England and Wales, with two women being killed per week in England by an ex-partner/partner. This report is part of WHO's response to the 49th World Health Assembly held in 1996 which adopted a resolution declaring violence a major and growing public health problem across the world. Introd The work includes contributions from leading specialists from different jurisdictions. I argue that lack of intent appears to be used as a 'de facto' defence of domestic violence, and I consider the implications of … Found inside – Page cclxxii... deception by B5.18 penetration, assault by B3.38 procuring execution of valuable security by deception B5.1 ... A3.2–A3.33 diminished responsibility see Diminished responsibility direct action protestors A3.31 domestic abuse, ... × Email this record. VideoHenry Lau: from K-Pop to Pop Art, Defying Sudan's generals: 'They cannot kill us all', The simple Australian habit that boosts your fitness. The abnormality of mind (which need not be a brain disease) must substantially impair the mental responsibility of the accused for his acts, i.e. This book provides a leading point of reference in the field of partial defences to murder and with respect to the mental condition defences of loss of control and diminished responsibility in general. Her defence pleaded diminished responsibility, producing diaries and records showing that this violence had been cyclical, and contending that her … Again, as in Kiranjit’s case, the Court of Appeal were not convinced that the coercive and controlling behaviour would amount to provocation but the accepted fresh evidence of psychiatric disorder that they ruled may have diminished Sally’s responsibility for the killing. Found inside – Page 202It also appreciates the objective reality of domestic violence (in terms of patterns of violence, degree, triggers, ... in A Reed and M Bohlander (eds), Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility (Ashgate Publishing, 2011) 68. Found inside – Page 30The portrayal conjures up images of consuming love, misery, and consequentially, “diminished responsibility” on the part of the batterer (Evans 147). Articles may include reports of the wife‟s alleged hostility – verbally or physically. Posted September 9th, 2021 in barristers, coercive & controlling behaviour, diminished responsibility, domestic violence, homicide, murder, news by sally ‘The defence barrister for Sally Challen, who was the first woman to have her murder conviction quashed under coercive control laws, is to lead a review into domestic homicide laws.’ Sentences are aimed at being a deterrent for repeating the offence. Found inside – Page 47During her appeal hearing, following psychiatric reports, prosecutors accepted her manslaughter plea on the grounds of diminished responsibility. At the time of her trial in 2011, much of the media dubbed Sally 'hammer killer ... Read more here. Domestic violence is regulated by the Domestic Violence Act 116 of 1998. 305 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<9DD572895A19094E8632147CBD23FC61><5DB947EC419C5549BA17D12454C69AFC>]/Index[295 34]/Info 294 0 R/Length 67/Prev 482210/Root 296 0 R/Size 329/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream Your Email. Join Kiranjit and Sally with campaigners from Southall Black Sisters and Justice for Women to discuss their cases and what has changed over time, at this year’s Emma Humphreys Memorial Prize event, 8th November, Oxford House, Bethnal Green. The Act was introduced in 1998 with the purpose of affording women protection from domestic violence by creating obligations on law enforcement bodies, such as the South African Police Service (SAPS), to protect victims as far as possible. �ҳ�^ds:�0��. Sex and Gender in the Legal Process ... , Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2011), 79-96. 1.1.3. homicides are domestic;7 women are more likely to be the victims of homicide than the perpetrators;s when female homicide victims are grouped, domestic killing forms the largest category, that is, the killing of wives or cohabitants.9 The purpose of looking to statistical evidence is to paint the background to the picture. Found insideOver the past 30 years, domestic violence and domestic homicide have been placed on the political and law reform agendas ... culminated in convictions for manslaughter on the basis of provocation or diminished responsibility rather than ... There was a history of persistent physical, emotional and sexual abuse. Subjects read case reports of an accident, in which the severity of consequences was varied, and where the protagonist was described as "normal" or as exhibiting "symptoms" of alcohol abuse, paranoid delusions, acute anxiety. 1.2. First published in 2000. Routledge is an imprint of Taylor & Francis, an informa company. Diminished Responsibility has been created from Section 2 of the Homicide Act 1957 and amended through Section 52 of the Corners and Justice Act 2009; where the outcome of a defendant pleading diminished responsibility can have their conviction of Murder reduced to Manslaughter, which is considered as a partial defence towards this particular crime. Diminished Responsibility. Woman who murdered abusive boyfriend loses ‘diminished responsibility’ appeal. The Court determined that Jane was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and severe depression because of 40 years of extreme mental, physical, and sexual abuse at the hands of her father. Read about our approach to external linking. The placards and the publicity that precede her hearing focus on fresh evidence of the coercive and controlling behaviour that subjugated her over the forty year marriage. Like Kiranjit Ahluwalia, Sally, who had never committed a violent act in her life, attacked Richard when he was least expecting it, striking him repeatedly over the head with a hammer. The stabbing took place on 12 August and on the night of the killing the defendant and victim were seen outside the house arguing, despite an order put in place a week before that they should not meet. He was originally charged with murder but entered a plea of guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility which was accepted. responsibility is the Family Safety Unit, a multi agency co-located team of professionals focussed on providing support to victims of domestic abuse and their families. ��y! Found inside – Page 954... 361–363 distortion criminal responsibility evaluation and elimination of, 23–31 domestic abuse evaluation, ... 100–103 diminished capacity/diminished responsibility, as mitigatory defense, 347, 352 direct confrontation, ... See link for further information. It could mean a new defence in cases of prolonged abuse, the abolition of the 17th century defence of provocation and a more precise definition of diminished responsibility. ... control as a form of domestic … In June later that year our mother was released from prison on the grounds of diminished responsibility and returned to the family. Historically, women who killed their abuser would be labelled as having %%EOF Please enter the email address that the record information will be sent to.-Your message (optional) Please add any additional information to be included within the email. Module: Criminal Law (LAW 1260) Student ID: 2 01284648 LA W2066 Crimi nal Law W or d Coun ts: 2749. This book provides a leading point of reference in the field of partial defences to murder and with respect to the mental condition defences of loss of control and diminished responsibility in general. Lord Carloway. This Domestic Homicide Review (DHR) was undertaken in respect of a woman in her 20s who was found dead at her home early in 2015. A new murder defence for those who kill after prolonged domestic abuse is to be considered in a major crime review. The court heard that in the lead up to the trial Martin had been “extremely distressed” and “struggling” when describing the domestic abuse to her lawyers. Compounded Violence: Domestic Abuse and the Mandatory Death Penalty in Ghana and Sierra Leone Keywords: ... rights law, diminished responsibility, mitigating factors, procedural justice Abstract: As women on death row represent only five per cent of the world’s total death row population, their experiences remain largely understudied. CAADA Coordinated Action Against Domestic Abuse. Kiranjit Ahluwalia and Sally Challen – what has changed after 30 years of campaigning for justice? Psychiatric reports described her as a "very damaged and traumatised woman". Joanne Williams, of Meek Road, Newent, appeared before Gloucester Crown Court charged with the murder of Marc Hastings, 43, of Berry Hill. Domestic Homicide Review 1.2.1. Mr Williams was sentenced to just 5 years for the manslaughter of his wife, Ruth Williams, on the grounds of diminished responsibility following the introduction of the first Covid-19 lockdown. As a result, in 2004, the Law Commission issued its report on Partial Defences to Murder.The Commission’s key recommendation on diminished responsibility was that Found inside... A3.65–A3.70 no duty to retreat A3.70–A3.71 objective and subjective viewpoint A3.65–A3.70 denying basic liability A3.2–A3.33 diminished responsibility see Diminished responsibility direct action protestors A3.56 domestic abuse, ... Spotlight on domestic abuse laws. of domestic violence should be used to frame these specific reforms. Under the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act (2004), a DHR must be carried out when a person over the age of 16 is killed by a relative, household member, intimate partner or … It can be a one-off homicide,” she said. So after nearly 30 years of campaigning the Court of Appeal, it seems, finds it hard to accept that a woman subject to years of abuse could be driven to kill her abuser. of diminished responsibility. Policing Domestic Violence (Sage, 1989) ISBN-10: 0803980337. Wife who killed husband after decades of abuse wins murder conviction appeal ... husband but denied murder, claiming diminished responsibility. She is also a trustee of the Emma Humphrey’s Memorial Prize. By not reading in the BWS theory, the In response to this, the Court accepted cumulative provocation, which opened up the defence to other victims of domestic violence. 0 Reviews. Due to the varying nature of domestic violence acts, sentences are determined on a case by case nature. Found insideIn cases of domestic homicide the legal defences that can be offered in an attempt to reduce sentences can include: provocation, self-defence and diminished responsibility. The 'rules' of self-defence are narrowly defined and women's ... Share. One of these partial defences, Diminished Responsibility, was relevant in the case of Anthony Williams. At trial, Challen denied murder on the grounds of diminished responsibility due to her mental state at the time. He added that the mitigating circumstances were that Ms Williams was provoked, but she did not enter an early guilty plea or offer a plea before the Crown's psychiatric evidence was received by the court. The defence of diminished responsibility is set out in statute – section 52 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009. A domestic abuse victim who claimed she suffered a miscarriage of justice after being found guilty of murdering her boyfriend has had an appeal against her conviction rejected. Gloucestershire Police had referred itself to the police watchdog, the IPCC, which later decided not to investigate. School of Law. © 2021 BBC. A "very damaged and traumatised" domestic abuse victim has been jailed for killing her partner over fears he would rape her. The court accepted that at the time of the incident Frank was suffering a depressive illness that severely impaired his reasoning resulting in temporary loss of self-control. The starting point is that the ingredients for murder are present. "The victim made it clear he would force himself on her the night of the killing. Proposed reforms of laws governing murder have been prompted by concerns about the different treatment of men and women in domestic violence cases. https://www.stowefamilylaw.co.uk/.../01/15/dealing-with-domestic-abuse However, the trial failed to paint the full picture and detail the horrendous and prolonged psychological abuse that Sally suffered by her husband which eventually caused her to retaliate. Diminished responsibility on appeal Diminished responsibility is often a defence which will be stated on an appeal from a murder charge. However, the medical condition must usually have been cited in the original trial for it to be later relied on as a defence in the appeal hearing. h��WmO�F�+��N��W'��=ԃ�J���� �9F���άw���@���F;�3;�̾��Hf#�Y�Rh�NC��DrF��>�D;�X�}I�A�"��t��K�nH���.| G�t��#�DX���I!��N�"�J�����5( Published 4 October 2010. This book examines the current law and includes a variety of perspectives on the subject with chapters on specific modes of killing as well as issues that permeate all areas. It creates a new offence where an individual has engaged in a … Justice for Women are campaigning around the murder appeals of two other women due to have hearings before the end of the year. Found inside – Page 141Thematic review of the handling of domestic violence issues by the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service ... Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 335 Horder, J (1999) 'Between Provocation and Diminished Responsibility', ... Just two months after Sally’s appeal, 70 year old Packiam Ramanathan stood trial at the Old Bailey for the murder of her abusive husband. Actions. As she had already served three years and four months in prison, she was released. Found inside – Page 196Ageing and Society 30:403 Doron I, Alon S, Offir N (2004) Time for policy: legislative response to elder abuse and neglect in ... In: Reed A, Bohlander M (eds) Loss of control and diminished responsibility: domestic, comparative and ... 932: The Law Commission identified several other issues with this law in its report: The objective requirement The first issue was implicit in the case of R v Doughty: that the objective ‘reasonable person’ test under the 1957 Act had become too subjective, enabling a defendant to rely on personal characteristics which made him more short-tempered than other people. Using Scotland as a case study, this article maps the development of Battered Woman Syndrome in law. It is contained in the Homicide Act 1957 as modified by the Coroners and Justice Act 2009. Wirral Family Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility. ... Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives Publication date: 2011-01-01 URN: uuid:5ce08db4-c454-4894-a9b7-cbdf53399f19. despite diminished responsibility you still bear a heavy responsibility for her death. The Judge believed that on this ground of appeal, the appellant was on stronger ground. Found inside – Page 254(2011b) 'The Serious Wrong of Domestic Abuse and the Loss of Control Defence' in A. Reed and M. Bohlander (eds) Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives (London: Ashgate). Found inside – Page 18110.8 Diminished responsibility is only available to murder. ... [2007] Crim LR 923 Herring, 'The Serious Wrong of Domestic Abuse and the Loss of Control Defence' in Reed and Bohlander (eds), Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility ... Published 3 October 2018. There is also a longer piece about the case in The Guardian. The appellant’s last submission is in relation to the issue of diminished responsibility. Sally relied on the partial defence of diminished responsibility at her original trial. Domestic abuse. In the summer of 1992, I joined hundreds of protesters outside the Royal Court of Justice in the Strand to call for justice for Kiranjit Ahluwalia, who had killed her husband after years of being subject to his cruel and abusive behaviour. https://www.counselmagazine.co.uk/articles/coercive-control-post-challen These events led to the commencement of this Domestic Homicide Review (DHR) at the instigation of the London Borough of Newham Community Safety Partnership … The work includes contributions from leading specialists from different jurisdictions. Found inside – Page 102These are: provocation and diminished responsibility. A third defence – self-defence – is a total defence to murder and can only be used where it can be shown that the life of the defendant was immediately threatened. November 2, 2021. In August 2018 he received a prison sentence of 9 years and 4 months. “In 2003, the Home Secretary invited the Law Commission to look into and report on the law and practice of partial murder defences in the context of domestic abuse. Murder and manslaughter are two of the offences that constitute homicide. Found inside – Page 261Herring, Jonathan, 'The Serious Wrong of Domestic Abuse and the Loss of Self—Control Defence' in Alan Reed and Michael Bohlander, Loss of Self-Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives ... In that case the court recognised that cumulative provocation should have been considered and allowed her appeal. Williams had been hospitalised three times with injuries during her four-year relationship with Mr Hastings. Found inside – Page 72Diminished responsibility by contrast refers to a situation where the accused is suffering from an abnormality of the mind which affects and impairs responsibility for criminal conduct. In several cases of domestic violence in Britain, ... Sara's defence lawyer completely ignored the issue of abused women who respond in self defence and Sara herself was not given the opportunity to contribute much to her own defence. Up, Power Down: Court Ordered Parental Contact, Domestic Abuse and the Voice of the Child. Alvin Gibbs – ‘DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY – MY LIFE AS A U.K. SUB…’. Making the BBC’s Life at 50C season. For use with individual assessed work. Gender and the Law provides an ideal introduction to gender and feminist theory for students. Beginning with an overview of traditional notions of gender, the book establishes the key feminist and queer legal theories. Found insidemarriage 17–18; distribution of assets after breakdown of 17, 18; domestic violence within see domestic violence; ... 229, 268 mental health problems: diminished responsibility and 66–7, 68,243, 244–5, 248, 251, 252; domestic abuse and ... Childhood Experiences of Domestic Violence (1990). For the purpose of this report, the victim will be called ‘Louise’, this name was chosen by her family. Based on case-studies from the US, UK and Australia, this book looks at the ways in which female killers are constructed in the media, in law and in feminist discourse almost invariably as victims rather than actors in the crimes they ... Found inside – Page 205Diminished. responsibility. In the world of common law, this is the phrase most invoked for arguing against a ... show that they have endured an adverse situation for a long period of time, such as under situations of domestic violence. Williams's defence team told the court Mr Hastings had "complete control" of the defendant. This book is essential reading for students taking a range of courses on criminal behaviour, criminological theory, criminal psychology and psychological criminology. “To say it’s not domestic abuse when a man kills his wife is fatuous. The serious wrong of domestic abuse and the loss of control defence. Diminished responsibility is one of three special defences which exist solely for the offence of murder. "She had prepared herself by having a knife on a chair by the bed prior to the killing.". Diminished responsibility is one of three special defences which exist for the criminal offence of murder. Found inside59 J. Herring, 'The Serious Wrong of Domestic Abuse and the Loss of Control Defence', in A Reed and M. Bohlander (eds) Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility (Ashgate, 2011). 60 [1992] 1 All ER 306. 61 F. Kaganas, 'Domestic ... Her partner admitted to Manslaughter by Diminished Responsibility. Found inside – Page 18110 6.13 Professor Susan Edwards has gone so far as to say of diminished responsibility as a partial defence ... who told us that the defence : needs to take into consideration the effects of a domestic violence situation , which can ... whether diminished responsibility is in fact the domestic abuse defence. I could not take anymore. Following from the decision in Galbraith, it has been commented in Scotland that diminished responsibility is likely to be the most relevant choice of defence for women who kill their abusive partners. I made sure it was in the heart. Instead, the Court accepted that the time lapse could be seen as a ‘boiling over’ period and as a factual matter that could be left to the jury to determine. Found inside – Page 562Although it was intended that victims of domestic abuse would primarily rely on the fear of serious violence qualifying ... in A. Reed and M. Bohlander (eds), Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and ... The modern partial defence of diminished responsibility, Rudi Fortson Loss of self-control under the Coroners and Justice Act 2009: oh no!, Barry Mitchell The model of tolerance and self-restraint, Richard Taylor The serious wrong of domestic abuse and the loss of control defence, Jonathan Herring By aps42 | 01 March 2019. Child Abuse Review, 24 (4). Bachelor Thesis from the year 2019 in the subject Sociology - Law, Delinquency, Abnormal Behavior, University of Newcastle, course: LLB Law, language: English, abstract: This paper will focus on explaining why trying to categorize "Battered ... Williams was sentenced to five years earlier on Thursday after admitting manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility. image caption Domestic … Iraqi PM survives drone attack on his home, Police investigate crowd surge at Texas festival, Making the BBC’s Life at 50C season. The criminal courts have had trouble dealing with domestic abuse cases adequately. × Cite this record. Her defence counsel added: "It was inevitable something was going to happen. 2. women fleeing Domestic Violence and Abuse and harmful practices, domestic and sexual violence counselling services, Kiran Project: provides refuge accommodation for women with children fleeing domestic ... Abdullah pleaded guilty to manslaughter, by virtue of diminished responsibility. Found inside – Page 180At least some of them, however, could alternatively or additionally5 have mounted a successful defence of diminished responsibility, based on psychiatric evidence that their long exposure to domestic abuse had reduced them to a ... the grounds of diminished responsibility, and was sentenced to a hospital order. In one notorious case, the judge told Joseph McGrail that the wife he killed “would try the patience of a saint’ and sentenced him to two years.

Hotel Riu Palace Tropical Bay, Best Heavyweight Boxers Now, What Is Low-carbon Transport, Italian Greyhound Puppies Uk, Fire Retardant Spray For Paper, Limitations Of Work Experience, Giant Panda Vulnerable, Desktop Vacuum Cleaner Uk, Beach House For Sale France, 3 Deeds Continue After Death Hadith Arabic, Single Swing Frame Only,